The Intersection of AI, Ethics, and Legal Obligations: A Brief Guide for Lawyers in eDiscovery and Litigation - Featuring BlueStar Case Solutions

The Intersection of AI, Ethics, and Legal Obligations: A Brief Guide for Lawyers in eDiscovery and Litigation - Featuring BlueStar Case Solutions

In the fast-paced, ever-evolving world of eDiscovery and litigation, lawyers are constantly seeking innovative ways to enhance their practice and maintain their professional standards. As artificial intelligence (AI) continues to make significant inroads into the legal profession, it is crucial for lawyers to consider how they can legally address the ethical standards they are bound to uphold. In this article, we will explore the intersection of AI and ethics, as well as potential solutions to assist lawyers in meeting their legal and ethical AI obligations. We will also discuss how BlueStar Case Solutions, a leading eDiscovery and litigation support service provider, can help lawyers navigate these challenges. 

1. Understanding AI's Role in the Legal Profession 

The integration of AI into the legal profession has enabled lawyers to streamline their processes, save time, and increase efficiency. AI-powered tools can assist with document review, case analysis, and legal research, enabling lawyers to focus on more strategic tasks. 

However, the use of AI in legal practice also raises several ethical concerns, such as: 

• Ensuring AI tools adhere to the standards of confidentiality and privilege 

• Maintaining competence and staying up-to-date with AI developments 

• Avoiding unauthorized practice of law by non-lawyers via AI tools 

• Ensuring AI tools are not biased or discriminatory in their outputs 

2. AI and Ethical Obligations 

As lawyers incorporate AI into their practice, they must be mindful of the ethical obligations outlined in the American Bar Association (ABA) Model Rules of Professional Conduct. A few key obligations relevant to AI include: 

• Competence (Rule 1.1): Lawyers must stay informed about changes in the law, including the benefits and risks associated with AI technology. 

• Confidentiality (Rule 1.6): Lawyers must maintain the confidentiality of client information, which may require them to ensure that AI tools are secure and respect client privacy. 

• Supervision (Rule 5.3): Lawyers must supervise non-lawyer assistants, including AI tools, to ensure that they are not engaging in the unauthorized practice of law. 

3. Addressing Ethical Concerns with AI 

To help lawyers navigate the ethical landscape of AI, here are some potential solutions: 

a. Thorough AI Vendor Assessment: Before selecting AI tools, lawyers should conduct a comprehensive assessment of AI vendors. This includes reviewing the vendors' security protocols, data handling policies, and understanding how the AI algorithms function to ensure compliance with ethical obligations. (BlueStar Case Solutions offers a stringent vetting process for AI-powered eDiscovery tools, ensuring that the selected technology aligns with the ethical obligations of legal professionals.) 

b. Continuous Learning and Training: Lawyers should stay up-to-date with AI advancements and engage in ongoing training to maintain competence. This will enable them to make informed decisions regarding the use of AI in their practice. (BlueStar Case Solutions provides regular training and educational resources on the latest AI technologies and best practices, empowering lawyers to make informed decisions regarding the use of AI in their practice.) 

c. Implementing Bias Checks: To mitigate the risk of biased AI outputs, lawyers should establish a system to check for potential biases in AI-powered tools. This may involve conducting periodic audits, reviewing AI-generated results, and collaborating with diverse teams to identify and address potential biases.  

d. Collaborative Decision-Making: Lawyers should not solely rely on AI tools for critical decisions. Instead, they should use AI as a supplementary tool to enhance their professional judgment and decision-making capabilities.  

4. The Future of AI and Ethics in the Legal Profession 

As AI becomes increasingly prevalent in the legal profession, lawyers must take a proactive approach to ensure that their use of AI tools aligns with the ethical standards outlined in the ABA Model Rules of Professional Responsibility. By staying informed about the technology, establishing effective supervision, and maintaining open communication with clients, lawyers can successfully navigate the challenges of integrating AI into their practice while upholding their legal and ethical obligations. With the support of experienced partners like BlueStar Case Solutions, legal professionals can confidently embrace AI as a powerful asset in eDiscovery and litigation. 

Our Blog RSS

BLUESTAR BUSINESS CONTINUITY PLAN AMID THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Dear Clients, Colleagues, and Friends,

At BlueStar, our thoughts and well-wishes are with you during these challenging times. We understand the difficulties and uncertainties you may be facing, and we are here to offer our support and assistance.

As we navigate the COVID-19 pandemic together, we want you to know that BlueStar remains fully committed to serving your ediscovery needs. Our team is available to you, operating remotely and following all necessary precautions to keep our employees and clients safe and healthy. Rest assured, our commitment to delivering top-quality service remains unwavering.

During this time of uncertainty, we recognize the importance of staying connected and supporting one another. If there is anything we can do to help, please do not hesitate to reach out. Thank you for being a valued client of BlueStar. We are deeply grateful for your trust and support, and we will continue to work tirelessly to earn it every day. If there is anything we can do to assist you in the weeks and months ahead, please don't hesitate to reach out. We are here for you and wish you all the best.

Sincerely, The BlueStar Team

Our Blog RSS

VIRTUAL ROUNDTABLE EVENT TO DISCUSS BUSINESS CONTINUITY AMID THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC

On April 7th, BlueStar held an exclusive virtual roundtable event to discuss business continuity amid the Covid-19 pandemic with thought leaders from a variety of organizations across the United States. The participants [1] featured representatives from Morgan Lewis, Winston & Strawn, Korein Tillery, Farmers Insurance, Bryan Cave, TechNoir Solutions, and BlueStar Case Solutions. Moderated by BlueStar’s Vice President of Client Solutions, Salvatore Mancuso, the discussion addressed pre-Covid-19 work policies, the “new norm” and challenges of working from home, current adoptions of existing and new technologies, and predictions of post-Covid-19 work life.

It goes without saying the degree to which this global pandemic has impacted society could not have been foreseen.  When Covid-19 emerged, the personal and professional lives of people around the world were abruptly changed forever.  Many were forced to make changes on the fly with very little notice.  Some changes were drastic while some were minor, and some changes will be temporary while others will be long lasting.  Recently, BlueStar brought together a panel of professionals from the legal and technology sectors via a virtual roundtable to discuss how some of these changes have affected their work lives and organizations they are employed by.

Moving away from the “Old-Norm” - From a professional standpoint, one of the biggest changes many of us had to make was moving from an office environment to a work from home or “WFH” setting. All of our participants were willing to candidly share that their organizations’ existing WFH policies were challenged beyond the majority of the participants’ expectations but, for the most part, were up for the challenge. Existing WFH policies spanned the gamut including a six-day per month WFH allowance while others required specific departments to maintain a full-time physical presence in the office. 

It seems that all of the represented organizations transitioned to WFH rather quickly - taking no more than a week to be fully operational again - albeit with some unforeseen challenges.  Some organizations thrived by bolstering their existing technology while others were already prepared for the level of impact this pandemic caused through their business continuity planning. One roundtable participant stated, “I was impressed and give credit to the IT teams and our preparedness plan. We were able to transition over two thousand employees to WFH within a day!” Many of the participants mentioned their respective organizations had already made an investment in cloud-based solutions and services – making email and network resources easily accessible for colleagues. However, as one participant mentioned, “a lot of things were stored on premise only.  No one imagined an entire firm working remotely so we had to make some adjustments.”  

The Impact - Between March 19th and March 23rd, in addition to many corporations and law firms transitioning to a WFH scenario, most schools moved to remote “e-learning” and, just like that, parents became tutors, wine was the new coffee, and pajamas were the new suit and tie. Most people across the nation, with the exception of essential workers, were instructed to shift to WFH and unfortunately some were even furloughed or laid off. Luckily, pre-existing policies and technology allowed for a smoother than expected transition for all of our participants. However, working from home brought new challenges as one participant noted, “Meetings within the organizations and with clients used to take place in conference rooms, restaurants, and coffee shops. We did not have to chase around a 2-year-old in between calls or play phone tag with someone who sat just several feet away a couple of weeks ago.”  Other challenges mentioned included: the screaming toddler in the background of conference calls, the family dogs barking for attention, and the necessity to share working space with significant others – just to name a few. The list is endless and contains new struggles for some but familiar norms for others.  An attorney in the group offered, “Lawyers at our firm are always expected to be on call all day and night so it was nothing new to us.” 

Employees not accustomed to working from home found themselves relying on technology to help facilitate communication. “It is a challenge when you are used to being able to walk to a colleague’s office and now must send an email or set up a virtual meeting,” offered one participant while another mused, “I miss the face to face and the office setting as I sit working solo at home – a change we had to adjust to overnight.”  

During our conversation, we also heard of organizations investing in new technologies to assist with making working from home as easy as possible while others were well prepared on the technology front and simply utilized their existing resources. Personnel within a few of the organizations represented at our discussion found themselves relying on their colleagues via impromptu training sessions to help with (re)training on how best to put available technology to use. Other organizations offered more formal training sessions – via video conferencing of course. 

One of our guests shared an ominous warning, “Since Covid-19 emerged there has been a malware increase of 475%.  Those working from home need to continue to be aware and take every precaution they can from clicking on links or attachments within emails from unknown senders.” Apparently, hackers have taken the Covid-19 situation as an opportunity to try to wreak even more havoc than usual. This is certainly one more thing for all of us to keep in mind during these unsettling times.   

The concept of innovation was also discussed.  Even before Covid-19 emerged, some of our thought leaders said their organizations had been investing in new technologies and approaches in order to be more accessible to their clients, improve internal efficiencies, and differentiate their organizations from the competition.  One of our participants was excited to share that his company’s transition to WFH was seamless and it encouraged their teams to think outside the box which included a new way to communicate through a proprietary app named Chatter 365[2].  “It’s a platform that quickly allows our organization to share important updates, brings our individuals and teams together in a collaborative environment and gets everyone out of email.” It appears these organizations are taking this pandemic challenge head-on via a creative approach with hopes of emerging from it in a better position than before.  

Embracing the “New Norm” and some Predictions - We asked our guests which solutions they may carry forward post-pandemic and their work-life predictions for the future. In response, we heard the long-term impact of all of this may not necessarily be negative. Many of the participants agreed this “new norm” has interestingly brought teams closer together even though individuals are physically located farther apart.  Others shared it has forced them to manage their time and workload better. New norm technology adoptions also included an increase in utilizing virtual meeting platforms such as Skype, GoToMeeting, and Zoom. “I think we will see more use of these virtual meetings. People may not have to necessarily travel as much going forward. These solutions could help organizations reduce costs,” was one comment we heard. Another participant added, “The concept of WFH and increasing our data security spend was more of a trend prior to COVID-19.  Tomorrow, it may just become a standard.” The new norm predictions also included a decrease in reliance on brick and mortar office space due to the apparent effectiveness of WFH, which, in the long run, may also prove to be more cost-efficient for many businesses. 

Takeaways Tips

1. Encourage weekly virtual team meetings (yes, we also count happy hours) to bolster cohesiveness and ensure everyone is on the same-page while working in unison towards individual and organizational goals. 

2. Make yourself accessible and be flexible. Communicate with your team and clients as much as possible. If you are partaking in childcare or have other non-work commitments, let your team and your clients know up front and schedule accordingly. Most will understand.

3. Offer educational content to your employees and clients in the form of documentation and/or online classes.

4. Prioritize training staff on the technologies you have adopted as well as WFH policies.

5. Create or review a “playbook” or business continuity plan to assure your organization is better prepared in the future to handle a pandemic such as Covid-19.  

6. Stay aware and vigilant about cyber security and data privacy. 

7. Take time to take care of yourself and your loved ones. A short walk or stint on the exercise bike can do wonders for one’s mindset and productivity.

[1] Participants:

Lauren Doerries – Global Information Governance & Business Process Manager, Morgan Lewis 

Joe Utsler – Litigation Support Manager, Farmers Insurance 

Scott Cohen - Managing Director - eDiscovery & Information Governance/Practice & Client Services, Winston & Strawn 

Christian Auty – Of Counsel, Bryan Cave 

James Velco – CIO/President, TechNoir Solutions 

Stephanie Clerkin – Director of Litigation Support, Korein Tillery 

Brent Gustafson – Vice President of Business Development, BlueStar Case Solutions

2 Chatter 365 – A BlueStar app designed by their sister company, Siemly Global.

Our Blog RSS